Caleb Williams vs Jalen Hurts: Dynasty Trade Value Comparison
Caleb Williams currently holds a 18% edge in Superflex dynasty value.
| Caleb Williams | Jalen Hurts |
|---|
| SF Value | 6,866 | 5,599 |
| Position | QB | QB |
| Team | CHI | PHI |
| Age | 24.7 | 28 |
| Rank | #15 | #23 |
The Case for Caleb Williams
Caleb Williams is 24.7, giving you a multi-year runway that matters in Superflex and justifies his QB15 price tag (6,866). Even after a -374 30-day dip, he still holds an 18.5% value edge over Hurts, which signals stronger long-term insulation. Chicago’s situation is trending toward a stable build around him, and any offensive step forward can re-rate his value quickly. If you’re buying talent plus time, Williams is the cleaner dynasty bet.
The Case for Jalen Hurts
Jalen Hurts is 28.0 and still squarely in his prime with a strong weekly ceiling, especially in Superflex. His +226 30-day trend shows the market is buying back in despite a lower overall value (5,599; QB23). Philadelphia’s offense is built to maximize him right now, keeping his short-term scoring profile elite. He’s the safer plug-and-play starter for teams chasing points immediately.
Verdict by Team Situation
If you're contending: Prefer Jalen Hurts for contenders because his current situation and weekly ceiling are built for immediate titles.
If you're rebuilding: Prefer Caleb Williams for rebuilders because he’s 3.3 years younger and still carries the higher insulated dynasty value despite the recent dip.
If value is close: If values are close, take Hurts if you’re starting him to win now; otherwise take Williams and demand a small add if you’re moving off the 18.5% value edge.
FAQ
Is Caleb Williams worth more than Jalen Hurts in dynasty? Yes—Williams is valued at 6,866 vs 5,599 for Hurts, an 18.5% gap in his favor. The age advantage (24.7 vs 28.0) drives the long-term premium despite Williams’ -374 30-day trend.
Should I trade Caleb Williams for Jalen Hurts? Only if you’re contending and Hurts is the missing piece at QB, because you’re giving up an 18.5% value edge. If you do it, try to get a plus (pick/young flex) back with Hurts.
Who is better in Superflex? For 2026 points, Hurts is the better Superflex starter profile; for multi-year value and roster insulation, Williams is the better Superflex asset.
Caleb Williams Full Profile | Jalen Hurts Full Profile | Trade Calculator
dynastytrademaker.com — AI-powered dynasty fantasy football trade tool. Try free