Rookie Watch: Week of September 17, 2026

Jaxson DartSELL

QB · NYG5,965

+805 Dart’s meteoric camp hype is paying dividends: he’s officially supplanted Daniel Jones and flashed plus arm talent against the Eagles, racking up 285 yards and 3 TDs. The Giants’ commitment to letting Dart work through mistakes is huge for his dynasty runway—his value jump looks real if the weapons stay healthy.

Emmett JohnsonSELL

RB · KC1,622

+550 Injuries have cracked open the Chiefs’ backfield, and Johnson’s burst and pass-game chops have him trending up fast. He’s already out-snapped Isiah Pacheco on third downs, and Andy Reid’s postgame praise signals staying power. If this usage holds, Johnson is a must-stash with RB2 upside.

Chris BellSELL

WR · MIA1,698

+528 Bell capitalized on a Jaylen Waddle injury, posting a 6-84-1 line in Week 2 and generating legit after-catch excitement. With Tyreek Hill’s contract situation looming, Bell’s dynasty arrow is firmly up—he could carve out a long-term role in Miami’s explosive offense.

+451 Strand was a surprise start after Desmond Ridder’s ankle injury and looked composed, especially on timing throws. Atlanta’s staff is reportedly “intrigued” by his upside; even if he returns to the bench, Strand’s value spike is worth a speculative hold in superflex leagues.

Jeremiyah LoveSELL

RB · ARI6,033

-854 The preseason darling has hit a wall: Love’s workload dwindled behind a resurgent James Conner and explosive rookie backup Trey Benson. Unless the Cardinals pivot soon, Love’s RB1 trajectory is in serious jeopardy.

Carnell TateSELL

WR · TEN3,520

-724 Tate’s camp hype hasn’t translated—he’s struggled with separation and logged just 2 catches through two weeks. The Titans’ stagnant offense isn’t doing him any favors, and his short-term outlook is murky unless he flashes soon.

J.J. McCarthySELL

QB · MIN1,033

-723 McCarthy’s value is sinking after a rough pair of starts, with turnovers and accuracy issues mounting. The coaching staff remains “committed” for now, but dynasty managers should be concerned about the potential for a midseason benching.

Drew AllarSELL

QB · PIT832

-658 Allar’s debut has been forgettable, with Pittsburgh’s offense sputtering and rumors of a quick hook swirling. He’s still a long-term bet, but immediate fantasy returns look bleak—stash only in deeper superflex formats.