J.J. McCarthy
Overall
#215
QB
#40
SUPERFLEX VALUE
1,033
1QB VALUE
553
Rank #245
Tier
33
Trade Frequency
0.3%
SF Premium
+480
DYNASTY OUTLOOK
J.J. McCarthy enters his rookie year in Minnesota with a clear developmental path behind Sam Darnold, limiting short-term fantasy relevance. Despite first-round draft capital, his dynasty value (SF 937) has dropped sharply, reflecting skepticism about immediate playing time and ceiling. McCarthy's strengths include above-average mobility, strong decision-making, and a track record of winning at Michigan, but concerns linger about volume, arm talent, and whether he can develop into more than a game manager. The presence of Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison is a long-term plus, but Minnesota's uncertain offensive line and run-heavy tendencies add risk. Given his low acquisition cost and insulated job security as a recent first-rounder, McCarthy is a speculative hold or buy for rebuilding teams, but not a priority target in shallow superflex leagues.
Auto-generated analysis · Updated every 3 days
VALUE PROJECTIONS
VALUE BY SCORING FORMAT
MARKET ACTIVITY
Value 📉: -478 in 30 days
J.J. McCarthy's dynasty value has been falling significantly over the last 30 days.
REAL TRADES (1,655 total)
Week 17 — From 1,655 trades across 497+ leagues
Week 17 — From 1,655 trades across 497+ leagues
Week 17 — From 1,655 trades across 497+ leagues
Week 17 — From 1,655 trades across 497+ leagues
SIDE B GETS
TRADE MCCARTHY?
Check what J.J. McCarthy is worth with our free calculator, or get AI-powered trade packages for your league.
AI TRADE VERDICT
AI TRADE VERDICT
Import your Sleeper league to get a personalized verdict: should you trade for this player given YOUR actual roster? The AI analyzes your team's strengths, weaknesses, and contender status to give a specific BUY / HOLD / SELL / AVOID recommendation with a trade package suggestion.
"BUY — Your roster is short on RB depth and you have WR capital to spare. Consider packaging a WR2 + mid-round pick."
Free — 30 credits included, no payment required
COMMUNITY PULSE
Be the first to vote
VALUE ADJACENT
MIN DEPTH CHART
DYNASTY TOOLS
HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISONS
Import Your League
See if J.J. McCarthy fits your roster. Get personalized trade suggestions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty trade value?
J.J. McCarthy has a Superflex dynasty value of 1,033 (overall #215, QB #40), based on FantasyCalc consensus data from 150,000+ real dynasty leagues, updated daily.
Is J.J. McCarthy a good dynasty asset right now?
J.J. McCarthy is a Tier 33 dynasty QB at age 23.7 on MIN. Whether to buy, hold, or sell depends on your contention window — the value trends and real trades on this page show how the market is treating him.
What should I expect in return when trading J.J. McCarthy?
Players with similar dynasty value include Drew Lock, Carson Beck, Shedeur Sanders. Use the free trade calculator to test exact packages against live market values.
How is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty value calculated?
Values come from FantasyCalc's consensus of real dynasty trades and markets across 150,000+ Sleeper leagues, refreshed daily — it reflects what managers actually pay, not one analyst's opinion.