Gardner Minshew
Overall
#382
QB
#63
SUPERFLEX VALUE
36
1QB VALUE
19
Rank #390
Tier
45
Trade Frequency
0.0%
SF Premium
+17
DYNASTY OUTLOOK
Gardner Minshew enters his seventh season as the presumed backup to Kyler Murray in Arizona. His 2023 stint as a spot starter for the Colts showed his typical competence but did not elevate his dynasty stock, as evidenced by a sharp 30-day value drop. Minshew offers short-term streaming upside if pressed into action, but lacks both elite traits and a clear path to a starting role. At age 30, his upside is limited to low-end QB2 production in rare spot starts. With comparable value to fringe prospects like Dillon Gabriel and Jarrett Stidham, Minshew is a hold only in deep superflex leagues and a clear sell if any spike in opportunity arises.
VALUE PROJECTIONS
VALUE BY SCORING FORMAT
REAL TRADES (139 total)
Week 17 — From 139 trades across 42+ leagues
SIDE A GETS
SIDE B GETS
Week 17 — From 139 trades across 42+ leagues
SIDE A GETS
SIDE B GETS
Week 16 — From 139 trades across 42+ leagues
SIDE A GETS
SIDE B GETS
Week 16 — From 139 trades across 42+ leagues
SIDE A GETS
TRADE MINSHEW?
Check what Gardner Minshew is worth with our free calculator, or get AI-powered trade packages for your league.
AI TRADE VERDICT
AI TRADE VERDICT
Import your Sleeper league to get a personalized verdict: should you trade for this player given YOUR actual roster? The AI analyzes your team's strengths, weaknesses, and contender status to give a specific BUY / HOLD / SELL / AVOID recommendation with a trade package suggestion.
"BUY — Your roster is short on RB depth and you have WR capital to spare. Consider packaging a WR2 + mid-round pick."
Free — 30 credits included, no payment required
COMMUNITY PULSE
Be the first to vote
VALUE ADJACENT
ARI DEPTH CHART
DYNASTY TOOLS
HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISONS
Import Your League
See if Gardner Minshew fits your roster. Get personalized trade suggestions.